Posts

Showing posts with the label Modernism

A "Moderate Islam" or the "Moderation of Islam"? - Ihsan al-Faqih

Image
A "Moderate Islam" or the "Moderation of Islam"? This title might cause some confusion, as one could mistakenly assume that "moderate Islam" and the "moderation of Islam" convey the same meaning—that they are synonymous. In reality, however, they are as far apart as the East is from the West, as the following lines will demonstrate. Following the events of September 11, Western research centers—representing contemporary Orientalism—took on the task of providing political leaders with reports identifying specific groups that should be supported to "modernize" the Islamic approach. The goal was to foster a "moderate Islam" that aligns with Western aspirations; a prominent example is the RAND Corporation report titled "Civil Democratic Islam: Partners, Resources, and Strategies." The report ultimately recommended supporting certain groups. Upon examining these groups and their methodologies, one finds that some are char...

What Exactly is "Moderate" Islam, and Where can we find it? - Rami Zahra

Image
“Moderate Islam” is merely a linguistic game whose function is to propagate triviality, ignorance, superficiality, and to disdain intellect on a broad scale.  “Moderate Islam” is a linguistic invention whose primary function is to propagate triviality, ignorance, superficiality, and disdain for intellect on a broad scale. Yet despite its frequent use in contemporary political and media discourse, the term itself remains undefined, ambiguous, and inconsistent both in Islamic tradition and in comparative religious studies. In my personal research into Islam, I sought to locate early Islamic or Qur’anic texts that explicitly define the concept of “moderate Islam.” I found none. Classical Islamic jurisprudential, theological, and philosophical texts do not employ the term “moderation” in this sense. At most, there is reference to “gentleness” — treating people with kindness and equality, and inviting them to submit to Allah “freely.” However, “gentleness” and “moderation” are conceptua...

Habib Ali al-Jifri & His Increasingly Problematic Statements

Image
  Habib Ali al-Jifri is well known for his numerous problematic, confusing, and deviant positions and statements. He is linked to Habib Umar by family ties and is part of the board of the institution Dar al-Mustafa in Tarim, Yemen. Habib Ali al-Jifri stated multiple times in public that he loves the Jews. He plays a major role in promoting interfaith dialogue, alongside other deviants like Hamza Yusuf and Abdullah bin Bayyah.  Various scholars, journalists, and writers have refuted and rebuffed him, but he continues in his extreme deviation.   In a recent post on X [29 September 2026, 5:19 PM], Habib Ali al-Jifri has stated that 'there are approximately 6.5 billion non-Muslims on Earth right now; my understanding of Islamic law is that most of them will not go to Hell!'    Habib Ali al-Jifri, in essence, is pushing the deviated and blasphemous idea that non-Muslims will be saved in the afterlife and will enter Jannah because they fall under the category of the '...

The Pro-Shia Galloway

Image
George Galloway is currently being promoted in South Africa and by radio stations that refer to themselves as Islamic.  Let us review some of the pro-Shia statements of this controversial person.  We must bear in mind that Galloway was working for the Shia channel PRESS TV too.  Can any Muslim allow a platform to be given to the person who uttered the statements collated below?    1. "_ On the day before Kabul fell to what were then known as the mujahidin, I told Mrs Thatcher in the House of Commons: ‘You have opened the gates to the *barbarians*, and a long, dark night will now descend upon the people of Afghanistan._’” - George Galloway He refers to the founders of the Taliban, those Deobandi students of deen, as 'barbarians'; source: https://highprofiles.info/interview/george-galloway/ 2. _I glorify the Hizbollah national resistance movement, and I glorify the leader of Hizbollah, Sheikh Sayyed Hassan Nasrallah._ George Galloway, 29 July 2006 Socialist Worker...

What have the Controversialists Achieved?

Image
In the modern era, a new meaning of moderation, i.e., i'tidaal, has emerged: ▪️Make innovations, i.e., bid'aat, permissible. ▪️Accept even the misguided. ▪️Confuse the forbidden, i.e., haraam, and the permissible, i.e., halaal. ▪️Erase the difference between guidance and misguidance. ▪️Abandon the prohibition of evil. ▪️Create loopholes in the rulings that are hard on the temperament or at least hide them. ▪️Do not use words like 'haraam'. ▪️Accept the people of falsehood as correct in their place. ▪️Keep a soft corner for all false religions and declare them as the truth in their own right. ▪️Erase the identity of the Sunni Muslim and become colored by the innovations of the people of innovation. In short, moderation, i.e., i'tidaal, and wisdom, i.e., hikmat, have now become the name of the aforementioned misleading ideas and wrong thoughts! ✍️... Mubin-ur-Rahman Mohalla Bilal Masjid New Haji Camp Sultanabad Karachi

The Fake and False Unity Slogans

Image
  1. When they closed the Masajid, despite being begged not to do so, there was no call for unity. 2. When they spied on Musallis, there was no call for unity. 3. When they signed the Global Imams Charter, they united with the Christians and Zionists and Buddhists, but there was no call for unity with the Muslim Ummah. 4. When they labelled the Sahabah radiyallahu 'anhum disparagingly, there was no call for unity. 5. When they called for unity with the Shia disbelievers and cast their brothers in a bad light, there was no call for unity. 6. When they labelled their own as controversial and problematic, there was no call for unity. 7. When they called the murderer and false prophet Khamenei "Imam", there was no unity with the Muslim Ummah 8. When they make horrible moves to modernise the Deen, they don't call for unity; rather, they push their distortions down the throats of others. 9. May the lies of accursed modernists and liberals follow them wherever they go. The s...

'Mainstream Islam'

Image
  The signatories of the controversial and problematic Global Imams and Scholars Charter have agreed upon what they refer to as 'mainstream Islam'.  The controversial and problematic charter has been signed without the consent of the general Muslim public, hence it falls under the umbrella of a select few who desire to polarize the Muslim Ummah, cause disunity, dissent, argumentation, and discord. The word 'mainstream', as selected by the organizations in the Global Imams and Scholars Charter is, in actual fact, very apt and suitable for them and the cause they pursue. An analysis of the word 'mainstream', as popularly used reveals some really interesting things. The word 'mainstream' is most often used with 'media', i.e., 'mainstream media'. Mainstream media faces significant criticism for declining trust, and is characterized by sensationalism, misinformation, and conflict of interest. In the same way, those who want to project an image...

Mufti Ahmad Khanpuri damat barakatuhum Addresses Free Mixing in the Name of Deen

Image
Click on the Above to Listen to the Audio Muftī Aḥmad Khānpūrī damat barakatuhum mentions in a response to one of the questions asked to him: Questioner: "These days people have started doing programs where men and women are seated in the same hall without a separation in between, and this is justified in the name of Da'wah. Even in some religious institutions and madaris, men and women now sit in the same room, with a barrier between them but with the instructor facing both. The people who do this say that people will stop coming if there is more proper gender separation, and they justify this by saying that this kind of set up does not fall under the prohibition of free mixing." Muftī Aḥmad Khānpūrī  damat barakatuhum answers:  "People like this will not be able to serve the Deen. People who have this kind of attitude that they can interpret things as they wish will end up disfiguring the Deen rather than serve it in any way. There is nothing really that can be sai...

Where are the Scholars of Modernity?!

Image
  The enlightenment thinkers and rationalists, as they like to be called, or the obscurantists, as I prefer to call them, have had a significant negative impact on the minds of young people. Sometimes they talk to them about Darwin and morality, other times about the layers of the sky and the physics of the earth, and yet, at other times they go to such lengths in their discourse that they believe no one but themselves adheres to the correct understanding of religion.  Since the beginning of the Al-Aqsa Flood and the outbreak of confrontation between Muslims and Jews, we haven't heard the voices of Adnan Ibrahim, Al-Kayyali, or their followers. Aren't these among the most important issues facing the Ummah? We haven't heard their opinions on these major issues! This battle has revealed the joints of the Ummah. It has shown us the enemy from the friend. Many have remained silent like the grave in the face of the crimes and aggression perpetrated against a Muslim people with t...

Modernism is Ugliness: Muhammad Zaki Hamad

Image
  To modern man - postmodern man: know that anything deviating from its course takes it from the realm of beauty into the absurdity of ugliness. The sun remains beautiful in its orbit ordained by Allah Ta'ala, and the moon remains luminous, sending forth its luminous tranquility by adhering to the limit set for it by Allah Ta'ala.  Likewise, everything in this world is subject to this, 'it is not for the sun to overtake the moon, nor does the night outpace the day. Each floats in its orbit.' [Qur'an 26:44] The greatest beauty for a servant is to adhere to the meaning of his servitude, for this is the requirement of reason and wisdom, especially for one who knows poverty and weakness, his limited understanding, and his weary thinking. Let him submit to the one who says to a thing, 'be', and it is. In all of this lies Shaytan's endless filth. Therefore, Allah Ta'ala has enjoined upon us not to worship Shaytan, but to dedicate our worship solely to Him,...

Evolution Apologists

Image
  Since it's inception, the theory of evolution has been controversial for Muslims. Through years of examining arguments for or against it, I have seen that accepting the theory of evolution is viewed as a sign of intellectual maturity. In contrast, adhering to the standard theological model of the origin of humanity is seen as dogmatic, possessing blind faith, or simply gross ignorance. In almost every Islamicate language, numerous books, articles, and pamphlets speak to the contention of whether Adam 'alayhi as-salam was an original creation.  Reconciliation with the theory of evolution came as numerous influential figures, both past and present, have taken the view that the Qur'anic narrative of Adam 'alayhi as-salam not having biological parents is connotatively speculative (zanni-ud-dalalah).  Muhammad 'Abduh proferred the view that the belief of Adam 'alayhi as-salam being the progenitor of all humans on earth today is not definitively (qat'i) known fr...

What if the Interfaith Question was Posed to the Pious Predecessors?

Image
  Sufyan Thawri rahimahullah was one of the great Muhaddithin of this Ummah. He lived from 97 to 161 AH.  Imam Dhahabi rahimahullah wrote about him, an entire book, called Manaqib Sufyan Ath-Thawri, from which the following 2 narrations are mentioned: 1. Damrah reports, I asked Sufyan Thawri, "Shall I shake hands with the Jews and Christians?" He said, "With your foot, yes." 2. I said to him, "What shall I say when I hear the sound of the Naqus (gong or bell)?" He said, "What do you say when a donkey passes wind?" Can we imagine for a moment what Sufyan Thawri rahimahullah would have said if the interfaith question was posed to him? What would he have said had he seen interfaith activities and prayers in which Muslims participate? Muslims today are under the impression that interfaith is synonymous with Da'wah. This image or impression has nothing to do with reality. Interfaith, and interfaith related activities like Mosque Open Days are noth...

Participating in a Meelaad Gathering - Fatawa Mahmudiyyah

Image
  Question: Zayd established a Madrasah in such a place where there are innovators, but he does not participate in any innovations. However, looking at the expediency of him not participating in the innovation, then these people will not send their children to the Madrasah. What is the ruling if he participates in their innovations? Assuming he participates in their Meelaad with the intention of Tabligh, what will be the status of this action of Zayd's? In such a situation, what should Zayd do? Some people say about Haji sahib that he had given permission to stand, looking at the expediency. Answer: Haamidan wa Musalliyyan It is not permissible for Zayd to participate in these gatherings of innovation for the expediency of the Madrasah. This has become like playing a fiddle and gathering people, then calling them for Salaah. There is no permission for this. It is not in our knowledge that Haji sahib had given permission to stand for the sake of running a Madrasah. And Allah Ta'...

Whitewashing Polytheism: The Mosque Open Day (Scam)

Image
  1. The Masjid is a sacred space . It is dedicated for the remembrance and glorification of Allah Ta'ala , Salaah , recitation of the Noble Qur'an , the learning and teaching of pristine and pure Islam .  2. There is no scope in Islam for the misuse or abuse of the Masjid .  3. In this day and age of trials and lies, one of the severest amongst them is the promotion of the blessed Masajid to be used as centers of interfaith harmony. We seek the protection of Allah Ta'ala from this blasphemy and polytheism. 4. The Masjid stands to elevate the name of Allah Ta'ala, and promote the true word of Islam as overpowering over every other system and religion.  5. Interfaith harmony stands in direct contrast with the message of Tauhid and Khatm-un-Nubuwwah.  6. The Mosque Open Day as advertised and promoted by Interfaith Advocates invites polytheists into the most sacred and pure space in order to 'encourage unity and inclusivity'. 7. A brief look at the history of the...

Who are the Sectarians?

Image
  Who are the Sectarians? What does Sectarianism mean? Who is responsible for Sectarianism, especially in the history of Islam? Hypocrites in the time of Rasulullah sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam During the lifetime of the final Nabi and Rasul of Allah Ta'ala deputed to humanity, Sayyiduna Muhammad Rasulullah sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam, there were a number of groups that the Muslims had to deal with. One was the polytheists, the other was the Christians, another was the Jews, then the Zoroastrians, and it goes without saying, the hypocrites.  The hypocrites caused immense harm to Rasulullah sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam; fleeing from battle, spreading false rumors about the messenger of Allah, siding with the polytheists time and again, siding with the Jews on multiple occasions, and despite being known for their vile deeds, they continued along as if nothing was wrong. Yet, they stood as a sect on their own, they were named in the Noble Qur'an as such, with their qu...