A "Moderate Islam" or the "Moderation of Islam"? - Ihsan al-Faqih
A "Moderate Islam" or the "Moderation of Islam"?
This title might cause some confusion, as one could mistakenly assume that "moderate Islam" and the "moderation of Islam" convey the same meaning—that they are synonymous. In reality, however, they are as far apart as the East is from the West, as the following lines will demonstrate.
Following the events of September 11, Western research centers—representing contemporary Orientalism—took on the task of providing political leaders with reports identifying specific groups that should be supported to "modernize" the Islamic approach. The goal was to foster a "moderate Islam" that aligns with Western aspirations; a prominent example is the RAND Corporation report titled "Civil Democratic Islam: Partners, Resources, and Strategies."
The report ultimately recommended supporting certain groups. Upon examining these groups and their methodologies, one finds that some are characterized by a bold, critical stance toward Islamic texts—whether through outright denial, reinterpretation, claims that the texts contradict reason, questioning the authenticity of their transmission (sanad), or asserting that they are no longer relevant to the modern age.
Others reduce Islam to a mere set of spiritual values and a private relationship between the Creator and the created—an approach that effectively marginalizes and excludes the Islamic framework from broader aspects of life.
Still others represent an isolationist, withdrawal-oriented approach, infused with ancient Eastern philosophies that focus exclusively on a human being’s spiritual ascent toward mystical revelation. All these groups—which the report advocates supporting—constitute what is meant by "moderate Islam" within the Western conceptual framework.
Meanwhile, within the Muslim world, there is profound confusion regarding the definition of "moderation" (wasatiyyah), stemming from a tendency to label a comprehensive commitment to the teachings of Sharia as "extremism" or "excessiveness."
In the midst of this chaos, the concept of "moderation" (wasatiyyah) is often used to justify evading certain—or even many—religious obligations, and to excuse the commission of forbidden acts, all under the pretext of "aligning with reality."
Within this chaotic environment, there is a tendency to rely on fringe, highly irregular, or exceptionally weak jurisprudential opinions.
Furthermore, the established principles—such as the balancing of interests and harms (masalih wa mafasid), the jurisprudence of priorities, and the jurisprudence of objectives (maqasid)—are distorted. They are stripped of their original purpose—which was to uphold goodness and righteousness—and are instead used to dilute religious rulings and manipulate scriptural texts to suit personal desires.
Under this distorted definition of moderation, fostering closeness with "the other" is prioritized over preserving the core framework of the Islamic creed, all in the name of "human coexistence" and the promotion of peace and love.
Consequently, what has come to be termed "moderate Islam" is, in reality, nothing more than the creation of a new version of Islam—one that aligns with Western interests, caters to personal whims, and serves specific political agendas.
Therefore, one must not fall into the trap of this deceptive call, which cloaks itself in the appealing terminology of "moderate Islam."
This call for a "moderate Islam" is fundamentally flawed. Islam does not require new versions to manifest moderation; rather, moderation is an inherent quality of its teachings and laws. It is, in fact, one of the most prominent characteristics of Islamic legislation. We need only return to the original methodology, not attempt to alter it.
Allah Ta'ala says: "And thus We have made you a just community [a middle nation] that you will be witnesses over the people and the Messenger will be a witness over you." [Al-Baqarah: 143].
In summary, the interpretations of this verse indicate that the concept of wasatiyyah (moderation/the middle path) is defined by the convergence of two elements:
1. Excellence (khayriyyah), or qualities denoting superiority, justice, or fairness.
2. An intermediate position (bayniyyah), whether in a physical or abstract sense.
If only one of these two attributes is present, the concept of wasatiyyah does not apply.
Examples of wasatiyyah in Islam include the concessions (rukhas) established by the Lawgiver for the benefit of the faithful—such as the permission to combine prayers during travel, or in cases of extreme cold, rain, or fear. These provisions are intended for challenging circumstances, ensuring that the community is not burdened by undue hardship.
Other examples include the permission for travelers and the ill to break their fast during Ramadan—with the requirement to make up the missed days later—or, for those with a chronic, incurable illness, the option to break the fast by providing a fidyah (a compensatory offering) instead of making up the days.
The wasatiyyah of Islam is also evident in the designation of the entire earth as a place of worship and a means of purification; prayer is valid in any location not known to be impure. This is further reflected in the principle of "original presumption of innocence/purity"—meaning that everything in life is considered pure unless Islamic law explicitly designates it as forbidden (which is rare) or provides evidence of its impurity (which is also very rare).
Furthermore, the wasatiyyah of Islam is manifested in its respect for and care for women’s rights, its honoring of human dignity, its commitment to justice and mercy toward non-Muslims, and its upholding of the rights of citizenship.
The manifestations of wasatiyyah within the Islamic framework are too numerous to be fully covered here. However, it is essential to emphasize that Muslims do not need a "new" Islam characterized by moderation; rather, they must return to the inherent wasatiyyah of Islam—a fundamental hallmark of its legal and ethical system. Ihsan Al-Faqih
Al-Sharq (Qatar)
Source:
https://al-sharq.com/opinion/15/11/2026/%D8%A5%D8%B3%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%85-%D9%88%D8%B3%D8%B7%D9%8A-%D8%A3%D9%85-%D9%88%D8%B3%D8%B7%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A5%D8%B3%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%85

Comments