Posts

Sayyidunā Ibrāhīm ‘alayhi as-salām Refutes Interfaith

Image
  The name of Sayyidunā Ibrāhīm ‘alayhi as-salām is being used widely to promote Interfaith. Let us stop for a moment to reflect if this ascription to him holds true or not, and whether Muslims can entertain such an idea or concept. Participants of an interfaith gathering or meeting or prayer take part in the event under the pretext that the deities worshipped by other religions are also true and that their religions are also valid. Hence, the foundation of interfaith meetings and gatherings is not da’wah, as interfaith advocates claim, but it actually entails acceptance of the idea that all religions are true. This is blasphemy. Period. Now, let us see from the Noble Qur’ān itself, what the views and actions of Sayyidunā Ibrāhīm ‘alayhi as-salām are regarding other religions. Moreover, the religion of Sayyidunā Ibrāhīm ‘alayhi as-salām will also be covered. Who was Sayyidunā Ibrāhīm alayhi as-salām and what religion did he follow? Indeed, Ibrāhīm was a [comprehensive] lead...

Critique of Aligarh College

Image
  When Sir Sayyed set up the foundations of Aligarh College, he sent a reliable friend of his to Gangoh in order to meet Mawl ā n ā Gangoh ī  rahimahullah  and give him the following message, “I have set up a college for the success and progress of the Muslims. This is because other nations have progressed and have gone far ahead but the Muslims are retrogressing. If you people help me in this cause, then I will be able to very quickly acquire my objective, which is, in reality, the success of the Muslims. The person came to Gangoh. After making sal ā m, he conveyed the message of Sir Sayyed. Mawl ā n ā  heard the message of Sir Sayyed and said, “Brother, until today we feel that the step towards success of the Muslims is following the commands of All ā h and His Ras ū l sallallahu 'alayhi wa sallam . However, it seems today that their success and progress lie in something else too. With regards to this matter, I can tell you that I have spent my entire life ...

Why Muslims can never embrace Interfaith, the Abrahamic Religion, or, Unity of Religions

Image
  1.       One of the principles of belief in Islām, which is established through consensus, is that there is no true Dīn, i.e., religion and way of life, except Islām. It is the final religion and it abrogates every previous religion, faith, or creed. 2.       The fundamental principle regarding the Noble Qur’ān is that it is the final scripture. It cancels every previous scripture revealed before it (the Taurāt, the Zabūr, and the Injīl etc.). 3.       It is binding upon Muslims to believe that previous scriptures have been cancelled and abrogated, and these scriptures have went through change and alteration at the hands of man.   Rasūlullāh ṣallallāhu ‘alayhi wa sallam once became very angry when he saw Sayyidunā ‘Umar Ibn Al-Khaṭṭāb raḍiyallāhu ‘anhu reading a page from the Taurāt. 4.       It is a fundamental belief in Islām that Sayyidunā Muḥammad Rasūlullāh ṣallallā...

CAN MUSLIMS ASSOCIATE WITH MODERNISTS?

Image
Ikhtilāf, or, Difference of Opinion, is of varying types and degrees. A broad overview of the subject shows that there are basically two types of Ikhtilāf. One is praiseworthy and the other is blameworthy. Ikhtilāf in subsidiary matters, where the principals and fundamentals adhered to by both parties involved are the same, is praiseworthy. This is because the aim and goal of both parties is to reach the truth. Ikhtilāf in principle matters and fundamentals is blameworthy, despised and looked down upon. An example of this is the Ikhtilāf (or Difference of Opinion) between a Muslim and a Christian; a Sunni and a Shia; or, as is the case in our current context, between a Traditional and a Modernist. The belief system, values and spirit of each party is different, and the aim or goal of each party differs too. Now, a vital question that arises is: how should we deal with, and treat a person who holds a position different to ours when it is of the second type, i.e., Ikhtilāf in Uṣūl? The c...

A Rejoinder to: Fiqh for Minorities - A Source Methodology and Framework Approach part 5

Image
  Fiqh for Minorities: A Source Methodology and Framework Approach by Mufti Muḥammad Haffejee was presented at the Southern African Ulama Conference, Eswatini [30 September 2022 – 2 October 2022]. The objective of the paper was covered in part 1 of the rejoinder. Part 2 of the rejoinder covered the sources of the ideas of new terms to be employed in Fiqh Al-Aqalliyāt. In part 3, the incident of the Noble Ṣaḥābah raḍiyallāhu ‘anhum who migrated to Ḥabasha was discussed. In part 4, the verse of the Noble Qur’ān presented as the source for ‘Fiqh for Minorities’ was presented with the explanation from the genuine and true scholars of Islām. In part 5, a response is presented to some of the issues raised by the advocate for Fiqh for Minorities. The following two aḥādīth must be borne in mind throughout the seemingly complex discussion on Fiqh for Minorities;   Sayyidunā Abū Najīh al-‘Irbād ibn Sāriyah raḍiyallāhu ‘anhu reports: Rasūlullāh ṣallallāhu ‘alayhi wa sallam delive...

A Rejoinder to: Fiqh for Minorities - A Source Methodology and Framework Approach part 4

Image
  Fiqh for Minorities: A Source Methodology and Framework Approach by Mufti Muḥammad Haffejee was presented at the Southern African Ulama Conference, Eswatini [30 September 2022 – 2 October 2022]. The objective of the paper was covered in part 1 of the rejoinder. Part 2 of the rejoinder covered the sources of the ideas of new terms to be employed in Fiqh Al-Aqalliyāt. In part 3, the incident of the Noble Ṣaḥābah raḍiyallāhu ‘anhum who migrated to Habasha was discussed. In part 4, the verse of the Noble Qur’ān presented as the source for ‘Fiqh for Minorities’ will be presented with the explanation from the genuine and true scholars of Islām. Mufti Muḥammad Haffejee quoted verses 7 and 8 of Sūrah Al-Mumtaḥinah as the need and basis for a ‘Fiqh for Minorities.’ Firstly, he has exposed his scant reading of the Tafsīr of the Sūrah and his strawman approach to the issue he supposedly wants the Muslim community to adopt. Shaykh Muḥammad ‘Alī As-Ṣābūnī raḥimahullāh states about Sūr...

A Rejoinder to: Fiqh for Minorities - A Source methodology and Framework Approach part 3

Image
  Fiqh for Minorities: A Source Methodology and Framework Approach by Mufti Muḥammad Haffejee was presented at the Southern African Ulama Conference, Eswatini [30 September 2022 – 2 October 2022]. The objective of the paper was covered in part 1 of the rejoinder. Part 2 of the rejoinder covered the sources of the ideas of new terms to be employed in Fiqh Al-Aqalliyāt. In part 3, clarity will be provided on the incident of the Noble Ṣaḥābah raḍiyallāhu ‘anhum who migrated to Habasha, and their blessed biographies will, Inshā Allāh, be purified from misrepresentation and the slander directed towards them. At the outset, it seems odd, or, co-incidental, or, convenient to notice the trend amongst advocates for Fiqh for Minorities to quote the incident of Habasha for their cowardly attempt to scuttle and subvert the Sharī’ah. Mufti Muḥammad Haffejee has employed his own Ijtihād, or has copied and pasted the Ijtihād of others, like Taha Jabir Al-Alwani to establish that Muslim Mino...